In January of 2005 the 16 superintendants of the Inter-County and Tri-County Leagues voted to merge the schools to form a new 16 member athletic league.  The member schools that make up the ITCL are:

Upper Tier:
-
2011 Columbiana Clippers (UPDATED)
-
2011 Crestview Rebels (UPDATED)
-
2011 East Palestine Bulldogs (UPDATED)
-
2011 Lisbon Blue Devils (UPDATED)
-
2011 Mineral Ridge Rams (UPDATED)
-
2011 South Range Raiders (UPDATED)
-
2011 Springfield Tigers (UPDATED)
-
2011 United Eagles (UPDATED)

Lower Tier:
-
2011 Jackson-Milton Blue Jays (UPDATED)
-
2011 Leetonia Bears (UPDATED)
-
2011 Lowellville Rockets (UPDATED)
-
2011 McDonald Blue Devils (UPDATED)
-
2010 Sebring Trojans
-
2010 Southern Indians
-
2011 Wellsville Tigers (UPDATED)
-
2011 Western Reserve Blue Devils (UPDATED)